California Says Corporations And LLCs Can't Be Directors; The Securities Exchange Act Apparently Believes Otherwise (2024)

Trending News

Dementia and the Forever Trustee: A Case for Age Limits?

Sanctions Considerations for Private Equity Firms – A Few Practical Tips

Federal Court Enters Consent Decree Against Rizo Lopez Foods Linked to Listeria Outbreak

Human Resources’ Role in Data Privacy and Cybersecurity, Part I: The Basics

Recent EEOC Activity and What to Watch For

OSH Law Primer, Part X: Voluntary Safety and Health Self-Audits

Credit Repair Company Fined $50M for Misleading Consumers

Private Market Talks: Conversations and Insights on the Private Markets with Private Capital’s Leading Figures.[Podcast]

HB Ad Slot

HB Mobile Ad Slot

Keith Paul Bishop

Email

949-851-5428

Bio and Articles

HTML Embed Code

HB Ad Slot

by: Keith Paul Bishop of - California Corporate and Securities Law

Thursday, November 16, 2023

California Says Corporations And LLCs Can't Be Directors; The Securities Exchange Act Apparently Believes Otherwise (3)

Related Practices & Jurisdictions

  • Corporate Business Organizations
  • Litigation Trial Practice
  • Administrative Regulatory
  • 9th Circuit (incl. bankruptcy)
  • California
  • Delaware

Print Mail Download />i

Nine years ago, I posed the question of whether the California General Corporation Law permits corporations to serve as directors. My answer at the time was "no" because Section 164 of the Corporations Code defines "director" to mean a natural persons. Courts applying Section 16(b) of the Securities Exchange Act have a different view, as illustrated by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals' holding in Roth V. Foris Ventures, LLC, 2023 WL 7482641. Securities lawyers will know that Section 16(b) imposes "short-swing" profits liability on greater than 10% beneficial owners, directors and officers. The Roth case involved the applicability Rule 16b-3, which exempts “[t]ransactions between an issuer and its officers or directors,” that are “approved by the board of directors of the issuer".

The Ninth Circuit found:

"Foris is only eligible for the [Rule 16b-3] exemption if it can show that it is a “director by deputization.” “[A] corporation may be a virtual director, and thus an insider for purposes of § 16(b) liability, by deputizing a natural person to perform its duties on the board." Because companies may incur Section 16(b) liability as directors by deputization, our court has recognized that they may also invoke the Rule 16b-3(d) exemption where the board is aware of the deputization.

quoting Dreiling v. Am. Express Co., 458 F.3d 942, 952 (9th Cir. 2006) (citation omitted).

The Court of Appeals declined to decide whether Foris was a director by deputization, and instead remanded the case to the District Court to make that determination. Of course, even should the District Court find that Foris was a director by deputization, this would not mean that Foris was an actual director as a matter of state corporate law.

Amyris, the issuer, in the case is a Delaware corporation. In case reader is wondering, Delaware also requires that directors be natural persons. 8 Del. Code § 141(b).

© 2010-2024 Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP

Current Public Notices

HB Ad Slot

HB Mobile Ad Slot

Current Legal Analysis

Human Resources’ Role in Data Privacy and Cybersecurity, Part II: Assessing Five Key Areas of Risk

by: Erin Schachter , Mercedes M. de la Rosa

USCIS Updates Guidance on EB-1 Extraordinary Ability Criteria

by: Miriam C. Thompson

USCIS Issues Updated Guidance on ‘Sought to Acquire’ Requirement of Child Status Protection Act

by: Nataliya Rymer , Natalie Gorelishvili

EPA Extends Enforcement Statement for Regulation of DecaBDE-Containing Wire and Cable Insulation in Nuclear Power Generation Facilities

by: Lynn L. Bergeson , Carla N. Hutton

EFSA Publishes Reports under NAMs4NANO Project

by: Lynn L. Bergeson , Carla N. Hutton

CFPB Supervisory Highlights Target Auto Finance Missteps

by: A.J. S. Dhaliwal , Mehul N. Madia

The BR International Trade Report: October 2024

by: Anthony Rapa , Joanne E. Osendarp

Hydro Newsletter - Volume 11, Issue 4

by: Tiffanie Ellis , Mealear Tauch

CFPB Permanently Bans Arbitration Company from Arbitrating Consumer Financial Disputes

by: A.J. S. Dhaliwal , Mehul N. Madia

California Passes Law Extending New Protections to Mortgage Borrowers

by: A.J. S. Dhaliwal , Mehul N. Madia

HB Ad Slot

HB Mobile Ad Slot

More from Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP

Did The FBI Violate The Securities Laws By Directing The Creation Of A Crypto Asset That Was Offered And Sold To The Public?

by: Keith Paul Bishop

Commission Grants Burrowing Owls “Candidate” Species Protections Under the California Endangered Species Act

by: Jennifer Jeffers

Stockholders Fail to Approve Proposal to Reincorporate Nevada Corporation in Delaware

by: Keith Paul Bishop

Two Commissioners Fault Lack Of Transparency In SEC Whistleblower Awards

by: Keith Paul Bishop

Corporation Proposes Fixes To Defective Amendments Increasing The Authorized Number Of Shares And Changing Name

by: Keith Paul Bishop

Governor Newsom Approves Key Housing Bill: AB 2243

by: Caroline Guibert Chase

California Legislators Exempt Themselves From New Disclosure Mandate

by: Keith Paul Bishop

Governor Signs Bill Mandating Pro Bono Disclosures By Lawyers

by: Keith Paul Bishop

New California Law Forbids

by: Keith Paul Bishop

Can AI Act With Scienter?

by: Keith Paul Bishop

Upcoming Events

Oct

15

2024

Employment Law Institute 2024

Oct

16

2024

Oct

30

2024

Oct

31

2024

ANTICIPATED BANKRUPTCY COURT ORDERED SALE: Body Details, Florida

More Upcoming Events

HB Ad Slot

HB Mobile Ad Slot

  • Print

California Says Corporations And LLCs Can't Be Directors; The Securities Exchange Act Apparently Believes Otherwise (9)

We collaborate with the world's leading lawyers to deliver news tailored for you. Sign Up to receive our free e-Newsbulletins

California Says Corporations And LLCs Can't Be Directors; The Securities Exchange Act Apparently Believes Otherwise (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Duane Harber

Last Updated:

Views: 6084

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duane Harber

Birthday: 1999-10-17

Address: Apt. 404 9899 Magnolia Roads, Port Royceville, ID 78186

Phone: +186911129794335

Job: Human Hospitality Planner

Hobby: Listening to music, Orienteering, Knapping, Dance, Mountain biking, Fishing, Pottery

Introduction: My name is Duane Harber, I am a modern, clever, handsome, fair, agreeable, inexpensive, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.